Following are all the milquetoast like words, in the list below.
PANTYWAIST
100% like milquetoast
SISSY
99.76% like milquetoast
MILKSOP
99.1% like milquetoast
PANSY
98.42% like milquetoast
MILKSOPPISH
33.45% like milquetoast
MEEK
33.45% like milquetoast
MILKSOPPY
33.45% like milquetoast
SOFT-MINDED
33.45% like milquetoast
MILK-LIVERED
33.45% like milquetoast
MINCED
33.45% like milquetoast
INDIFFERENT
33.45% like milquetoast
MEASLY
33.45% like milquetoast
NAMBY-PAMBY
33.45% like milquetoast
WIMPY
33.45% like milquetoast
MIGHTLESS
33.45% like milquetoast
GUTLESS
33.45% like milquetoast
SPINELESS
33.45% like milquetoast
TIMID
33.45% like milquetoast
DAFT
33.45% like milquetoast
MILK-AND-WATER
33.45% like milquetoast
FAINTLING
33.45% like milquetoast
SLIGHT
33.45% like milquetoast
WEAK-KNEED
33.45% like milquetoast
WEAK-HANDED
33.45% like milquetoast
WEAK-MINDED
33.45% like milquetoast
INVERTEBRATE
33.45% like milquetoast
TARDY
33.45% like milquetoast
MIFFY
33.45% like milquetoast
LOW-HEARTED
33.45% like milquetoast
MEDIOCRE
33.45% like milquetoast
LESS-THAN-STELLAR
33.45% like milquetoast
SOFT
33.45% like milquetoast
MEAN
33.45% like milquetoast
BEGGARLY
33.45% like milquetoast
LACKLUSTER
33.45% like milquetoast
MISVENTUROUS
33.45% like milquetoast
WEAKSAUCE
33.45% like milquetoast
SIMPLE
33.45% like milquetoast
PENCIL-NECKED
33.45% like milquetoast
OBTUSE
33.45% like milquetoast
SMALL
33.45% like milquetoast
CHéTIF
33.45% like milquetoast
SECOND-RATE
33.45% like milquetoast
YELLOW
33.45% like milquetoast
UNDERWITTED
33.45% like milquetoast
WEAK
33.45% like milquetoast
LILY-LIVERED
33.45% like milquetoast
MINSITIVE
33.45% like milquetoast
CALLOW
33.45% like milquetoast
INVALOROUS
33.45% like milquetoast
THREADBARE
33.45% like milquetoast
FAINT-HEARTED
33.45% like milquetoast
COWARDLY
33.45% like milquetoast
DULL-WITTED
33.45% like milquetoast
FLIMSY
33.45% like milquetoast
MOULDY
33.45% like milquetoast
MEAGRE
33.45% like milquetoast
MEAGER
33.45% like milquetoast
THEWLESS
33.45% like milquetoast
LOWMINDED
33.45% like milquetoast
MOCKWORTHY
33.45% like milquetoast
PUSILLANIMOUS
33.45% like milquetoast
NIMWITTED
33.45% like milquetoast
UNPREPOSSESSING
33.45% like milquetoast
UNVALOROUS
33.45% like milquetoast
CHINLESS
33.45% like milquetoast
SOFTHEADED
33.45% like milquetoast
LOWLY
33.45% like milquetoast
IMBECILE
33.45% like milquetoast
ROUND-HEELED
33.45% like milquetoast
LACKWIT
33.45% like milquetoast
WISHY-WASHY
33.45% like milquetoast
MUZZY
33.45% like milquetoast
MICKEY MOUSE
33.45% like milquetoast
MENIAL
33.45% like milquetoast
LUSTLESS
33.45% like milquetoast
HALF-WITTED
33.45% like milquetoast
INEFFECTUAL
33.45% like milquetoast
WUSSIFIED
33.45% like milquetoast
SHABBY
33.45% like milquetoast
ROUGH AROUND THE EDGES
33.45% like milquetoast
SILLY
33.45% like milquetoast
TRINKETY
33.45% like milquetoast
UNDERAMBITIOUS
33.45% like milquetoast
LOW-BRED
33.45% like milquetoast
LOW-MINDED
33.45% like milquetoast
DEPRECATED
33.45% like milquetoast
SKIMPING
33.45% like milquetoast
TREMULOUS
33.45% like milquetoast
SLIMSY
33.45% like milquetoast
SO-SOISH
33.45% like milquetoast
WHITE-LIVERED
33.45% like milquetoast
MULLET-HEADED
33.45% like milquetoast
DOTARDLY
33.45% like milquetoast
GORMLESS
33.45% like milquetoast
CLOWNISH
33.45% like milquetoast
ILL-MANNERED
33.45% like milquetoast
CRAVEN
33.45% like milquetoast
POOR
33.45% like milquetoast
CRUMMY
33.45% like milquetoast